Unit 12 · Multi-Step Conditional Reasoning
Four Friends at a Restaurant — Preference Intersection
Lesson 2 of 16
Preference Intersection questions are among the most approachable in this unit — the challenge isn't complex logical reasoning but systematic, methodical elimination. Your job is to find the one option that passes through every person's acceptance filter simultaneously, which becomes trivial once you stop trying to track everyone in your head at once.
These questions appear in the easy-to-medium band of OC TS and are near-certain marks for students who use a grid. The trap for unprepared students is trying to reason about all four people simultaneously — they miss one person's constraint and pick a cuisine that two of them actually can't eat.
The examiner wants to confirm that you can build a systematic compatibility check — listing each person's valid options — and then find the single choice that gets a tick from every person. Speed is not the challenge; discipline and completeness are.
Four or five people each have preferences or restrictions (e.g. "only likes X and Y", "will eat anything except Z"). A list of options is given. You must find the single option that every person agrees on. Exactly one option always satisfies all constraints simultaneously.
Best approach: Draw a quick grid: people as rows, options as columns. Mark each cell ✓ (acceptable) or ✗ (rejected). The answer is the column that is all ticks. For speed: start with the most restrictive person — the one who accepts fewest options — and immediately cross out any option they reject. Then check whether the remaining options work for everyone else.
Question
Four friends want to eat at one restaurant together. The food court offers Japanese, Italian, Mexican, and Thai.
- Amir likes every cuisine except Thai.
- Bella and Cian only like Japanese and Italian.
- Dana will eat anything except Japanese.
Which single cuisine could all four agree on?
Select an answer to see the explanation.
Give Your Child the Best Chance at OC Entry
Join NSW families preparing their children for the Opportunity Class Placement Test with the most realistic online OC practice tests available. First tests free—no credit card required.
Claim Your Free OC Practice Tests