Thinking Skills
Four friends (Leo, Maya, Sam, and Ruby) were ranking their favourite weekend activities: Swimming, Cycling, a…
Question 1 · Multiple choice
Question
Four friends (Leo, Maya, Sam, and Ruby) were ranking their favourite weekend activities: Swimming, Cycling, and Tennis.
| Clues: |
|---|
| - Leo liked Swimming more than Cycling. |
| - Only Maya liked Tennis more than Cycling. |
| - Sam and Ruby both liked Swimming more than Tennis. |
| - No one liked Cycling the least. |
Options
What is the maximum number of friends who could have liked Swimming the most?
- A.1
- B.2
- C.3
- D.4
Correct answer
Explanation
Logic puzzles like this are like being a detective. The tricky part isn't what the rules say, but what they secretly mean! Let's break it down together.
Step 1: The "Only" Clue (The Secret Rule)
Look at the second rule: "Only Maya liked Tennis more than Cycling." If Maya is the only one who feels this way, what does that mean for the other three friends? It means Leo, Sam, and Ruby must feel the opposite. So, our secret rule is: Leo, Sam, and Ruby all like Cycling more than Tennis.
Step 2: Finding Last Place
The last rule tells us: "No one liked Cycling the least." Now, think about Leo, Sam, and Ruby. We just figured out they like Cycling more than Tennis. If Cycling cannot be in 3rd place, then Tennis must be in 3rd place (last) for Leo, Sam, and Ruby.
Step 3: Building the Rankings
Now let's look at each friend to see who could possibly have Swimming as their number one choice:
- Leo: We know he likes Swimming > Cycling (Rule 1), and we know Tennis is his last place. His exact list must be: 1. Swimming, 2. Cycling, 3. Tennis. (That's 1 person for Swimming!)
- Sam and Ruby: We know Tennis is their last place too. The rules also say they like Swimming more than Tennis, which makes sense. That means their top two spots are Swimming and Cycling. Because the question asks for the maximum number of kids who could have Swimming first, we are allowed to put Swimming in 1st place for both of them! (That's 2 more people for Swimming!)
- Maya: She likes Tennis > Cycling. But remember, no one is allowed to have Cycling in last place. Tennis and Cycling must fill her top two spots (Tennis 1st, Cycling 2nd). Swimming is therefore forced into last place. She cannot have Swimming first.
The Result: Leo, Sam, and Ruby can all have Swimming as their number one choice. Maya cannot. Therefore, the maximum number is 3.
Summary Table
| Friend | Key Constraints | Forced Order | Swimming First? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leo | Swimming > Cycling; Tennis is last | Swimming > Cycling > Tennis | ✅ Yes |
| Sam | Swimming > Tennis; Tennis is last | Swimming > Cycling > Tennis (for max) | ✅ Yes |
| Ruby | Swimming > Tennis; Tennis is last | Swimming > Cycling > Tennis (for max) | ✅ Yes |
| Maya | Tennis > Cycling; Cycling not last | Tennis > Cycling > Swimming | ❌ No |